Carl Robert Holty

Federation

Found at Christies, New York
THE HOUSE SALE, Lot 125
1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Estimate: 1.500 - 2.500 USD
Price realised: 1.200 USD
Carl Robert Holty (1900-1973)
Federation
signed 'Holty' (lower right)
oil on canvas
16 x 24 in. (40.6 x 61 cm.)

Auction result misses estimated price range

When the work Federation by Carl Robert Holty was auctioned at Christies in New York in March 2005, the result was somewhat disappointing. The auction house had previously given the estimated price as a range of USD 1,500.00 – 2,500.00, of which not even the lower limit was reached - in fact, the artwork changed hands for USD 1,200.00 (€ 925.28). Of course, this price has nothing to do with the top prices that other works by Carl Robert Holty achieve. The highest price we have observed so far was reached by the work without title in July 2021 with an auction result of USD 75,600.00 (€ 63,722.18).

Auktionsergebnis verfehlt die Schätzpreisspanne

Als die Arbeit Federation von Carl Robert Holty im März 2005 bei Christies in New York versteigert wurde, fiel das Ergebnis ein wenig enttäuschend aus. Das Auktionshaus hatte den Schätzpreis zuvor mit einer Spanne von USD 1.500,00 – 2.500,00 angegeben, von der nicht einmal die Untergrenze erreicht wurde - tatsächlich wechselte das Kunstwerk für USD 1.200,00 (€ 925,28) den Besitzer. Dieser Preis hat freilich nichts mit den Spitzenpreisen zu tun, die andere Arbeiten von Carl Robert Holty erzielen. Den höchsten von uns bisher beobachteten Preis erreichte die Arbeit ohne Titel im Juli 2021 mit einem Auktionsergebnis von USD 75.600,00 (€ 63.722,18).

Other artists in this auction

Henry Pember Smith - A Venetian Canal
Henry Pember Smith
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Venetian Canal
Price: 7.200 USD
Found at Christies
20 auction results
William Sergeant Kendall - Figure On A Path, Brittany
William Sergeant Kendall
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Figure On A Path, Brittany
Price: 3.120 USD
Found at Christies
5 auction results
Antonio Cirino - Morning Walk
Antonio Cirino
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Morning Walk
Price: 6.600 USD
Found at Christies
7 auction results
Frederick Judd Waugh - The Caribbean
Frederick Judd Waugh
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: The Caribbean
Price: 3.360 USD
Found at Christies
52 auction results
Walter Koeniger - Breakers On The Shore At Dusk
Walter Koeniger
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Breakers On The Shore At Dusk
Price: 1.920 USD
Found at Christies
14 auction results
William Trost Richards - Homage To The Sea
William Trost Richards
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Homage To The Sea
Price: 7.800 USD
Found at Christies
116 auction results
John Francis Murphy - Autumn Landscape
John Francis Murphy
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Autumn Landscape
Price: 2.160 USD
Found at Christies
41 auction results
George Wainwright Harvey - Early Fall Coloring, Sand Dunes,  Annisquamis, Massachusetts
George Wainwright Harvey
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Early Fall Coloring, Sand Dunes, Annisquamis, Massachusetts
Price: 4.200 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Adolf Arthur Dehn - Pennsylvania Winter
Adolf Arthur Dehn
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Pennsylvania Winter
Price: 2.640 USD
Found at Christies
17 auction results
Henry Hobart Nichols - Farmhouse In A Mountainous Landscape
Henry Hobart Nichols
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Farmhouse In A Mountainous Landscape
Price: 4.800 USD
Found at Christies
5 auction results
Christian J. Walter - Early Moon Rise
Christian J. Walter
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Early Moon Rise
Price: 7.800 USD
Found at Christies
4 auction results
Charles T. Phelan - A Flock of Sheep Grazing In A Landscape
Charles T. Phelan
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Flock of Sheep Grazing In A Landscape
Price: 6.000 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Anna Richards Brewster - Landscape With A Canal
Anna Richards Brewster
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Landscape With A Canal
Price: 9.600 USD
Found at Christies
4 auction results
John William Hill - A Fisherman By A Waterfall
John William Hill
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Fisherman By A Waterfall
Price: 2.400 USD
Found at Christies
9 auction results
William Merritt Post - A Wooded Landscape
William Merritt Post
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Wooded Landscape
Price: 1.920 USD
Found at Christies
4 auction results
Robert Bruce Crane - November Meadows
Robert Bruce Crane
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: November Meadows
Price: 4.200 USD
Found at Christies
40 auction results
James Gale Tyler - Indian Summer At Newport Beach
James Gale Tyler
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Indian Summer At Newport Beach
Price: 6.960 USD
Found at Christies
35 auction results
Thomas Doughty - Along The Lake Shore
Thomas Doughty
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Along The Lake Shore
Price: 6.000 USD
Found at Christies
18 auction results
James Macdougal Hart - Threatening Weather
James Macdougal Hart
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Threatening Weather
Price: 7.800 USD
Found at Christies
16 auction results
Ralph Albert Blakelock - A Wooded Landscape With A Figure On A Path
Ralph Albert Blakelock
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Wooded Landscape With A Figure On A Path
Price: 4.560 USD
Found at Christies
38 auction results
Sophus Jacobsen - A Nocturnal River Landscape
Sophus Jacobsen
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Nocturnal River Landscape
Price: 3.840 USD
Found at Christies
12 auction results
Norman Prescott Davies - The Visitor
Norman Prescott Davies
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: The Visitor
Price: 3.360 USD
Found at Christies
5 auction results
Charles Courtney Curran - Wood Nymph Study
Charles Courtney Curran
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Wood Nymph Study
Price: 9.600 USD
Found at Christies
40 auction results
Richard la Barre Goodwin - Basket of Strawberries
Richard la Barre Goodwin
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Basket of Strawberries
Price: 3.120 USD
Found at Christies
18 auction results
Daniel Huntington - Portrait of A Lady In A White Dress, Said To Be Emily Astor
Daniel Huntington
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Portrait of A Lady In A White Dress, Said To Be Emily Astor
Price: 3.000 USD
Found at Christies
7 auction results
George Edwards - A Natural History of Uncommon Birds: Four Plates
George Edwards
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Natural History of Uncommon Birds: Four Plates
Price: 1.560 USD
Found at Christies
27 auction results
Alexander Helwig Wyant - Sunlit Clearing
Alexander Helwig Wyant
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Sunlit Clearing
Price: 5.760 USD
Found at Christies
39 auction results
Mary Cassatt - The Manicure
Mary Cassatt
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: The Manicure
Price: 4.800 USD
Found at Christies
312 auction results
Bruno Lucchesi - Pope John
Bruno Lucchesi
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Pope John
Price: 900 USD
Found at Christies
6 auction results
Charles Nicolas Sarka - Tribesmen, Morocco
Charles Nicolas Sarka
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Tribesmen, Morocco
Price: 360 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Albert Edward Sterner - Woman In A Green Blouse
Albert Edward Sterner
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Woman In A Green Blouse
Price: 3.120 USD
Found at Christies
5 auction results
Everett Shinn - Two Men Conversing From The Mystery of Edwin Drood, Chapter 9
Everett Shinn
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Two Men Conversing From The Mystery of Edwin Drood, Chapter 9
Price: 360 USD
Found at Christies
81 auction results
Andrew Fisher Bunner - Rhine-Boats On The River Maas, Off The Coast of Dordrecht, Holland
Andrew Fisher Bunner
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Rhine-Boats On The River Maas, Off The Coast of Dordrecht, Holland
Price: 3.120 USD
Found at Christies
4 auction results
Jerome Myers - Huber\'S Museum
Jerome Myers
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Huber'S Museum
Price: 540 USD
Found at Christies
31 auction results
Alfred Jonniaux - Portrait of Robert David Lion Gardiner (1911-2004), In An Officer\'S Uniform
Alfred Jonniaux
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Portrait of Robert David Lion Gardiner (1911-2004), In An Officer'S Uniform
Price: 7.800 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
George Benjamin Luks - A Man Holding A Staff
George Benjamin Luks
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Man Holding A Staff
Price: 960 USD
Found at Christies
45 auction results
William van Zandt - Henry J. Stewart And Lady Hill, Greenwich, New York
William van Zandt
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Henry J. Stewart And Lady Hill, Greenwich, New York
Price: 4.800 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
William James Glackens - Study of A Lady Wearing A Hat
William James Glackens
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Study of A Lady Wearing A Hat
Price: 840 USD
Found at Christies
112 auction results
John Sloan - Waiting
John Sloan
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Waiting
Price: 2.640 USD
Found at Christies
139 auction results
Richard Hayley Lever - Sailboats On A River
Richard Hayley Lever
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Sailboats On A River
Price: 16.800 USD
Found at Christies
84 auction results
Frank Myers Boggs - Across The Canal, Nemours
Frank Myers Boggs
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Across The Canal, Nemours
Price: 6.600 USD
Found at Christies
79 auction results
Robert Frederick Blum - Fishermen At A River\'S Edge, Holland
Robert Frederick Blum
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Fishermen At A River'S Edge, Holland
Price: 19.200 USD
Found at Christies
26 auction results
Karel Appel - A Creature
Karel Appel
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Creature
Price: 5.400 USD
Found at Christies
1,582 auction results
Henry Moore - Draped Reclining Figure, From Nudes, (Cramer 33)
Henry Moore
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Draped Reclining Figure, From Nudes, (Cramer 33)
Price: 840 USD
Found at Christies
2,977 auction results
Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec - Les Vieilles Histoires, Couverture-Frontispiece
Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Les Vieilles Histoires, Couverture-Frontispiece
Price: 2.040 USD
Found at Christies
1,681 auction results
Roberto Matta - Alexander Kahan, Centre Noeuds
Roberto Matta
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Alexander Kahan, Centre Noeuds
Price: 3.360 USD
Found at Christies
1,168 auction results
Leonard Baskin - Adder\'S Tongue
Leonard Baskin
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Adder'S Tongue
Price: 120 USD
Found at Christies
24 auction results
Marc Chagall - Fables, By Jean de la Fontaine
Marc Chagall
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Fables, By Jean de la Fontaine
Price: 960 USD
Found at Christies
6,286 auction results
Raoul Dufy - Figures In A Garden
Raoul Dufy
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Figures In A Garden
Price: 2.040 USD
Found at Christies
1,627 auction results
Edward Linley Sambourne - Great Queens of History; Also Goodbye Sailor
Edward Linley Sambourne
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Great Queens of History; Also Goodbye Sailor
Price: 840 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Natalia Dumitresco - Composition # 7
Natalia Dumitresco
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Composition # 7
Price: 780 USD
Found at Christies
293 auction results
Lee Gatch - Untitled
Lee Gatch
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Untitled
Price: 1.800 USD
Found at Christies
10 auction results
Irene Rice Pereira - Two Dancing Figures
Irene Rice Pereira
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Two Dancing Figures
Price: 960 USD
Found at Christies
38 auction results
Nicolai Ivanovich Fechin - Study of A Mexican Man In Profile
Nicolai Ivanovich Fechin
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Study of A Mexican Man In Profile
Price: 8.400 USD
Found at Christies
91 auction results
Joseph Antonio Hekking - Autumn Lake
Joseph Antonio Hekking
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Autumn Lake
Price: 1.200 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Bernard Lamotte - A View of A Park, Paris
Bernard Lamotte
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A View of A Park, Paris
Price: 2.880 USD
Found at Christies
9 auction results
Moses Soyer - Woman In An Interior
Moses Soyer
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Woman In An Interior
Price: 3.000 USD
Found at Christies
73 auction results
Edward Cucuel - Paris At Night
Edward Cucuel
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Paris At Night
Price: 7.800 USD
Found at Christies
119 auction results
Emil Ganso - Adjusting Her Shoe
Emil Ganso
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Adjusting Her Shoe
Price: 2.400 USD
Found at Christies
4 auction results
William Henry Lippincott - River Landscape With A Barn
William Henry Lippincott
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: River Landscape With A Barn
Price: 960 USD
Found at Christies
6 auction results
Alexander Brook - Ned
Alexander Brook
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Ned
Price: 2.280 USD
Found at Christies
6 auction results
Jerry Farnsworth - Helen
Jerry Farnsworth
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Helen
Price: 6.600 USD
Found at Christies
3 auction results
Martha Walter - Entering The Mosque
Martha Walter
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Entering The Mosque
Price: 2.640 USD
Found at Christies
105 auction results
Herbert Haseltine - A Saddled Donkey
Herbert Haseltine
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: A Saddled Donkey
Price: 4.800 USD
Found at Christies
31 auction results
Harry Jackson - Hazin\' In The Leaders
Harry Jackson
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Hazin' In The Leaders
Price: 4.200 USD
Found at Christies
66 auction results
André Gisson - Rain Drenched Streets, Paris
André Gisson
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: Rain Drenched Streets, Paris
Price: 4.560 USD
Found at Christies
35 auction results
George Henry Smillie - New Jersey Landscape With A Figure Resting By A Tree
George Henry Smillie
Auction: 1. MAR - 2. MAR 2005
Title: New Jersey Landscape With A Figure Resting By A Tree
Price: 5.760 USD
Found at Christies
12 auction results